Ask any volunteer manager what keeps them awake at night and managing difficult volunteers will be high on the list. The long-serving volunteer who will not accept change, two team members who no longer speak, the person whose comments upset service users: these situations are common, stressful and rarely covered in anyone's job description. This guide offers a practical, fair approach, from preventing problems to handling conflict and, occasionally, ending someone's involvement.
Managing difficult volunteers: focus on behaviour, not people
The phrase ‘difficult volunteer’ is a useful shorthand, but it can get in the way. Almost always, the problem is a behaviour in a particular context, not a person's whole character. Framing it that way helps you stay calm, be specific and keep the door open to things improving. It also makes it easier to be fair, because you are responding to what someone did, not to how you feel about them.
Why problems arise in volunteer teams
Understanding the cause often points to the solution. Common causes include:
- Unclear expectations. The volunteer genuinely does not know where the boundaries are.
- Change. New systems, new staff or new ways of working can feel like a loss, especially to long-serving volunteers.
- Unmet needs. Someone who wanted social contact, recognition or more responsibility, and is not getting it.
- Personal circumstances. Illness, bereavement, money worries or stress outside volunteering.
- Group dynamics. Cliques, informal leaders and old disagreements.
- A poor fit. The role simply does not suit the person.
Look at your own organisation honestly too. If problems keep appearing in the same team or role, the cause may lie in how the role is designed, how change was introduced or how the team is led, rather than with any one volunteer. Fixing the system often resolves several individual issues at once.
Prevention: clear roles, clear standards, regular contact
The best way of managing difficult volunteers is to make difficulties less likely in the first place.
- Give every volunteer a clear role description. Our guide to writing a volunteer role description shows how.
- Agree a short, plain-English code of conduct covering respect, confidentiality, safeguarding and how to raise concerns.
- Hold regular support meetings, so small issues surface early. See our volunteer supervision guide.
- Involve volunteers in changes that affect them, and explain why changes are happening.
- Have a written problem-solving procedure, so everyone knows what will happen if things go wrong.
The early, informal conversation
Most issues are best resolved with a calm, private conversation, as soon as you notice a pattern. Waiting rarely helps. A simple structure:
- Describe what you have seen, specifically and without labels: ‘At the last two sessions, you spoke over new volunteers when they asked questions.’
- Explain the impact: ‘Two of them told me they felt uncomfortable coming back.’
- Listen. Ask for their view and what might be going on. You may learn something important.
- Agree what will change, and any support you will offer.
- Set a time to review, and thank them for talking with you.
Keep a brief note of what was discussed and agreed. It helps if things do not improve.
Resolving conflict between volunteers
Conflict between team members can spread quickly if left alone. Try these steps:
- Speak to each person separately first, to understand their perspective.
- Look for practical fixes, such as rota changes or clearer task allocation, that remove friction.
- If both are willing, bring them together for a facilitated conversation with agreed ground rules: one person speaks at a time, focus on the future, agree specific actions.
- Consider independent mediation for long-standing or serious disputes.
- Follow up with both people afterwards, and watch the wider team for knock-on effects.
A fair process when things do not improve
Sometimes informal conversations are not enough. A volunteer problem-solving procedure gives you a fair, consistent route. Avoid the word ‘disciplinary’, which belongs to employment; ‘resolving problems’ or ‘problem-solving procedure’ works better. A typical procedure includes an informal stage, a more formal meeting where the volunteer can bring a companion, a written outcome and a chance for the volunteer to ask for a review by someone else.
If behaviour may be linked to a disability or health condition, talk about what support or adjustments might help before moving to a formal stage.
Behaviour that needs immediate action
Some situations cannot wait for a staged process. These include safeguarding concerns, violence or threats, theft, harassment or serious breaches of confidentiality. In these cases, you may need to ask the volunteer to step back from their role while you look into what happened. Explain that this is a neutral step, not a judgement. If anyone is in immediate danger, call 999, then tell the Designated Safeguarding Lead. Our article on safeguarding volunteers explains more.
A conversation planner for difficult situations
Before the conversation, write down:
- What specifically happened, when and who was affected.
- Which part of the role description or code of conduct this relates to.
- What you do not yet know, and the questions you want to ask.
- Any support or adjustments that might help.
- What a good outcome would look like.
- When and how you will review progress.
Afterwards, record: the date, who was present, what was said, what was agreed and the review date.
Look after yourself too. These conversations are tiring. Talk to your own manager, and do not carry difficult situations alone.
Managing difficult volunteers well is a skill, and it gets easier with practice and a clear framework. Our Managing Difficult Volunteer Situations and Dealing With Difficult Behaviour training modules give managers and volunteers practical techniques, and Managing Groups covers team dynamics.
Frequently asked questions
Can you ask a volunteer to leave?
Yes. Volunteers do not have employment rights, and volunteer agreements are binding in honour only. Even so, it is good practice to follow a fair, consistent problem-solving procedure, explain your reasons and offer a review, except where immediate action is needed to keep people safe.
Do volunteers have a right to a grievance procedure?
Volunteers do not have a legal right to a grievance procedure in the way employees do, but having one is good practice. A clear, simple way for volunteers to raise concerns helps you resolve problems early and fairly.
How do I handle conflict between two volunteers?
Talk to each person separately first, look for practical fixes, then, if both agree, hold a facilitated conversation with ground rules and specific actions. For long-standing or serious disputes, consider independent mediation, and follow up afterwards.