Ask volunteers what worried them before their first shift and you will hear the same things again and again: ‘What if I say the wrong thing?’, ‘What if someone asks me something I don’t know?’, ‘What if I get it wrong in front of people?’ Those worries are normal, and they are one of the main reasons people hesitate or drop out early. Building volunteer confidence is not a soft extra. It is part of preparing people to do their role well, and training is one of the best tools you have.
This article looks at why confidence matters, what knocks it, and how to design training that leaves volunteers feeling ready rather than overwhelmed.
Why confidence matters as much as knowledge
You can give a volunteer every piece of information they need and still find they hold back. Knowing what to do and believing you can do it are different things. A volunteer who knows the safeguarding procedure but is too anxious to raise a concern has not really been prepared.
Confident volunteers tend to:
- Ask questions when they are unsure, rather than guessing
- Raise concerns early, including safeguarding concerns
- Handle small problems without escalating everything
- Try new tasks and take on more responsibility over time
- Enjoy their volunteering, which makes them more likely to stay
Confidence also links directly to retention. Volunteers who feel out of their depth are far more likely to stop coming, often without saying why. We explored that link in volunteer training and retention: what the evidence says.
What knocks volunteer confidence
Before designing training, it helps to understand what undermines confidence in the first place. Common causes include:
- Unclear roles. Not knowing where your responsibilities start and stop.
- Being thrown in. Starting without induction, shadowing or a named person to ask.
- Jargon. Acronyms and in-house language that make newcomers feel like outsiders.
- A bad early experience. A difficult customer or an awkward conversation in week one.
- Life experience. Some volunteers come to you after illness, redundancy, bereavement or years of caring, and may be rebuilding confidence more generally.
- Feeling judged. Training that feels like a test rather than a chance to learn.
Building volunteer confidence through training: seven principles
- Start with what people already know. Most volunteers bring skills from work, family and community life. Asking them to share these early shows that they have something to offer.
- Make it safe to get things wrong. Set ground rules at the start: questions are welcome, mistakes are how we learn, and nobody will be put on the spot.
- Practise before the real thing. Short role-plays, scenario cards and ‘what would you do if…’ discussions let volunteers rehearse tricky moments.
- Break learning into small steps. A volunteer who masters one thing feels ready for the next. Long lists of everything at once do the opposite.
- Give specific, positive feedback. ‘You listened really well there and checked what she meant’ is more useful than ‘well done’.
- Name the support. Make sure everyone leaves knowing exactly who to contact and when.
- Follow up. A quick check-in after the first few shifts lets you spot worries before they turn into reasons to leave.
Activities that work well
Some training activities are particularly good at building confidence:
Scenario discussions
Small groups talk through realistic situations: a customer who is upset, a client who shares something worrying, a colleague who is rude. Discussing it in a group spreads the pressure, and volunteers hear that others would feel unsure too.
Skills swaps
Volunteers pair up and teach each other something they are good at, connected to the role or not. It reminds people that they are capable, and it builds relationships.
Assertiveness practice
Many volunteers find it hard to say no, set a boundary or ask for help. Simple assertiveness techniques, practised in pairs, can make a real difference to how people cope with pressure.
Personal action plans
Ending a session with each volunteer writing down one or two things they will try gives them a sense of direction, and gives you something to ask about at the next check-in.
Supporting volunteers who are rebuilding confidence
For some people, volunteering is part of a bigger journey back to confidence, perhaps after mental ill health, unemployment or a long period of caring. Training can help a great deal, but it needs a little extra thought:
- Offer a quiet conversation before group training to talk through any worries
- Let people choose whether to take part in role-plays or observe first
- Keep groups small where you can
- Offer self-study materials so people can prepare at their own pace
- Celebrate progress, however small
How to tell if it is working
Confidence is hard to measure, but you can track it in simple ways:
- Ask volunteers to rate how confident they feel about the role before and after training
- Notice whether volunteers raise questions and concerns more readily
- Listen to what coordinators and staff say about new volunteers in their first months
- Watch for volunteers taking on new tasks or responsibilities
- Ask your newest volunteers what made them nervous before they started, and what helped.
- Add a short scenario discussion to your next induction session.
- Check that every volunteer knows who to contact if they are unsure, and how.
- Arrange shadowing for anyone starting a new role.
- Add a before-and-after confidence question to your training evaluation.
Frequently asked questions
How do you build confidence in new volunteers?
Give them a clear picture of the role, a chance to practise in a safe setting, someone to shadow, early tasks they can succeed at, and regular feedback. Confidence grows from small successes and from knowing exactly who to ask when they are unsure.
Is confidence training only for volunteers who lack confidence?
No. Most volunteers feel uncertain about something, whether it is a difficult conversation, using a till or speaking up in a team meeting. Confidence-building activities help everyone, and they are particularly valuable for people returning to activity after illness, caring or time out of work.
What is the difference between confidence and competence?
Competence is being able to do the task; confidence is believing you can. Volunteers need both. Training builds competence through knowledge and practice, and builds confidence through encouragement, feedback and the experience of getting things right.
Training modules that help
Our Confidence Building for Volunteers training module is a ready-to-run three-hour session designed for exactly this, with activities, trainer hints and handouts. For volunteers who struggle to say no or speak up, Beginning Assertiveness for Volunteers offers practical, gentle techniques you can deliver in-house.