Every volunteer manager eventually faces the same budget question: do we bring in an external trainer, or do we run the training ourselves? There is no single right answer, but there is a right answer for your organisation. This guide compares in-house volunteer training with external trainers on the three things that matter most: cost, quality and control. It is written for small and medium charities, where budgets are tight and the volunteer manager is often the trainer, the recruiter and the person who makes the tea.
The two options in brief
External trainers are freelance or agency trainers, or staff from a larger organisation, who come in to run a session. You pay for their time, expertise and usually their materials.
In-house volunteer training is delivered by your own staff or experienced volunteers, using materials you have written yourselves or bought in. You pay in time rather than fees, plus the cost of any materials.
Many organisations use both. The question is which suits each topic, and where your money and time go furthest.
Cost: what you actually pay
External training can look affordable as a one-off, but the costs add up when you need to train volunteers regularly.
Think about how often you need to run each session. If new volunteers join throughout the year, you may need induction training four or more times a year, plus refreshers on safeguarding, confidentiality and other core topics. Paying an external trainer every time quickly becomes one of the larger items in a small volunteering budget.
In-house training has costs too, and it is important to be honest about them:
- Staff or volunteer time to prepare and deliver sessions
- Time to write or adapt materials, unless you buy them ready-made
- Printing, refreshments and sometimes a venue
- Time to keep materials up to date when law or guidance changes
The biggest hidden cost of in-house training is usually writing the materials from scratch. A good half-day session takes many hours to design properly. Using ready-made materials that you adapt removes most of that cost.
Quality: who delivers better training?
It is easy to assume an external specialist will always deliver better training. Often they will be more polished. But polish is not the same as relevance.
Where external trainers tend to be stronger
- Specialist and technical topics, such as first aid, food hygiene or manual handling
- Courses that lead to a recognised certificate
- Sensitive topics where an outside voice helps people speak freely
- Bringing fresh ideas and examples from other organisations
Where in-house volunteer training tends to be stronger
- Explaining your own policies, procedures and ways of working
- Using real examples from your services (with personal details removed)
- Building relationships between volunteers and the people who will support them
- Answering ‘what do we do here when…’ questions on the spot
- Following up afterwards, because the trainer is still around
Control: timing, content and consistency
Control is where in-house volunteer training has the clearest advantage.
- Timing. You can run sessions when new volunteers start, in the evening or at weekends, or for a single volunteer if needed, without waiting for a trainer’s diary.
- Content. You decide what is covered and can adapt it to each role.
- Consistency. Using the same session plan every time means every volunteer gets the same core messages, whoever delivers it.
- Records. You keep the attendance and evaluation records yourself, which helps with funders and quality standards.
A simple way to decide
For each topic on your training plan, ask:
- Does this topic need a recognised qualification or certificate? If yes, use an accredited external provider.
- Is it mainly about how we do things here? If yes, deliver it in-house.
- Do we need it more than twice a year? If yes, in-house is likely to be better value.
- Do we have someone who can lead a group confidently, with good materials? If not yet, consider developing them, or use an external trainer while you do.
- Would an outside voice help? For example, with a topic that touches on staff and volunteer tensions.
Making in-house volunteer training work
If you decide to bring more training in-house, a few things make the difference:
- Start with ready-made materials. A trainer guide with a timetable, activities and trainer notes, handouts and slides means you are adapting rather than writing.
- Add your own examples. Swap in your policies, contacts and real situations.
- Develop your trainers. Give coordinators a chance to observe, co-deliver and then lead.
- Evaluate every session. Short feedback forms tell you what is landing and what needs changing.
- Keep records. Who attended, when, and what was covered.
- List every training session you ran or paid for last year, and roughly what each cost in fees and time.
- Mark which topics are mainly about your own ways of working.
- Pick one of those to bring in-house first, ideally induction.
- Identify a coordinator or experienced volunteer who could co-deliver it.
- Find ready-made materials you can adapt rather than starting from a blank page.
Frequently asked questions
How much does an external volunteer trainer cost?
Typical charity rates for an external trainer are roughly £300 to £650 for a half-day session, before travel, venue and materials. Rates vary by region, topic and the trainer’s experience, so always ask for a full quote.
Do we need to be expert trainers to deliver training in-house?
No. You need to know your organisation and your volunteers, be comfortable leading a group discussion, and have good materials to work from. A clear trainer guide with timings, activities and notes does much of the heavy lifting, and confidence grows quickly with practice.
When is it better to use an external trainer?
When the topic needs specialist knowledge you don’t have in-house, when you need an accredited or certificated course, when an outside voice will help with a sensitive issue, or when your team simply has no capacity. Many organisations mix the two.
Where to start
Induction is usually the best place to begin, because you run it most often and it is all about your organisation. Our Introduction to the Organisation training module gives you a full session plan and materials to adapt. If your coordinators need help with the wider role of supporting volunteers, Supporting and Supervising Volunteers is a good companion. You can browse every topic in the training library.